2025 PSDG: The Most Overvalued Rookies Based on Early ADP (Preview)
Chris Rito 7/11/2025
As training camp buzz kicks into full gear, fantasy managers are salivating over the new crop of 2025 NFL rookies. The draft class boasted plenty of talent, but not every first-round pick is destined for instant fantasy greatness. Early average draft position (ADP) data is showing some inflated hype for rookies who might disappoint based on their situation, role, or development curve.Here’s a look at five big-name rookies who are currently overvalued in redraft formats, and why fantasy managers might want to tap the brakes.
1. Ashton Jeanty, RB, Las Vegas Raiders (ADP: RB5)
Why He's Overvalued:Jeanty is being drafted as a high-end RB1 ahead of established players with great recent histories and performance…based largely on Jeanty’s draft position (6th overall), new coach Pete Carroll’s history of running the ball, and the Raiders’ desperate need for some offensive punch. But the reality...
This is a Premium FF Mastermind Article.
You must be logged in to view it.
The Definitive Fantasy Information Service
Mastermind Moment
Week #8: The Market Debuts - FREE Sneak Peek!
Tuesday, October 21st, 2025
Tuesday - 10/21/2025: Premium Weekly Fantasy Newsletter subscribers take note. Your wait is OVER! The most important portion of the newsletter has been released for your viewing pleasure.
Read the Full Mastermind Moment
Testimonials
-- Brian I.
"First year as a FF Mastermind Premium Subscriber and first year winning our league championship. Coincidence??? I don't think so! Thanks Mike!"
-- Mike St. Clair
"I'd like to thank Fantasy Football Mastermind for all their great information this year. I was in five leagues this year. I made the playoffs in four of the leagues, had the best record in three leagues, went to the championship in three leagues."
-- Fred Masterjohn
"Thanks a ton for all your work on IDP information and analysis - very grateful as I am just leaving for the draft now. That's why FFMastermind blows all others services away."
-- Steve Ward
"Your 4th & One Injury Report is much better than other premium reports I've seen. Keep up the great work!"
-- Bobby C.
"Great job with another SI.com Championship- clearly you rule that kingdom with FOUR championships in a row! And to win it being the #4 seed, too. Awesome job!"
-- John Pittman